The abrupt end to the 2020 NCAA gymnastics season was a shock to everyone, us included. And while we understand and support the measures being taken to prevent the spread of COVID-19, it means that a lot of us are suddenly left with extra time on our hands…
Which is why we’ve decided to embark on an important journey, one that will take us back through one of television’s most important series to date: Make It or Break It. Every Saturday (and a number of other bonus days) from now until the 2021 season, our editors Katherine, Kalley and Claire will be breaking down and recapping each episode of everyone’s favorite gymnastics show.
Want to watch along? You can find MIOBI on Hulu and the Freeform app, all you have to have is a subscription/cable login. You can also buy the DVDs or purchase seasons or single episodes on various platforms, like iTunes. Join us in the cheesiness and the early 2010s TV gymnastics by using the hashtag #MakeItOrBreakItDown on Twitter as you watch.
You can read our S1E1 recap here.
Episode 5: I Won’t Dance, Don’t Make Me
So I immediately thought of this lyric in this song:
Kaylie’s father comes out of exile at the hotel to visit her and she says she wants him to be her manager again because they “share the same drive.” Dad-agers…I have questions.
Lauren asks Carter if their relationship is only about sex and he says no. In my opinion, the worst time to ask this is after you’ve (presumably) just had sex, but the answer would probably be just as ludicrous regardless.
After we get this coronavirus under control, I want medical funds diverted to a study that tracks 18 year olds who claim they “take love very seriously” and their ensuing divorce rates.
At the gym, the girls are speculating on which local harlot Austin Tucker will be showing up to the gym with that day. When he arrives, guess who it is?
Emily says she hitched a ride with Austin because her car was having issues. If that’s true, that makes the girls’ ensuing responses even more capitalistically evil, since they freak out on her for getting involved with boys. It’s the (gendered) economy, stupid.
It’s time for the girls to start prepping their floor routines for world team tryouts. The Rock has enlisted the help of an expert fast food franchise cashier, so I can’t wait for the final product.
Lauren, disgusted at the idea of working with a pedestrian instructor, sets to work looking for more Hollywood-level abilities. Because she’s going onto America’s Got Talent, not worlds team tryouts.
In a shocking turn of events, Payson’s already annoyed because Sasha wants her routine to be more artistic.
The imagery Sasha espouses to Karen from Wendy’s references flowers and butterflies a little too much for me to take it seriously. Can’t wait for the music to be an instrumental version of the “Veggie Tales” theme song.
Steve and Chloe are making out in the gym lobby when Kaylie’s mom comes in and is justifiably disgusted. Her ensuing comment (surely made out of spite for the fact that she currently doesn’t have a man) makes her a truly phenomenal contender for the Real Housewives of Boulder.
Chloe finds out that Kaylie’s dad will be managing her now, and she decides it’s a brilliant idea for her to do the same for Emily. Repeating that Kris Jenner GIF because it’s more applicable now.
Her first act as Emily’s fixer manager is to call choreographers at the behest of Steve Tanner, but all she knows are Vegas promoters, so I’m fully expecting a drag queen to show up and I can’t WAIT.
Carter shows up and apologizes for that morning’s awkward conversation about sex. Lauren proposes they go on a date to make up for it, forgetting to make any calls to the elite choreographers who’ll make her dreams come true. Funny how focusing boys and not gymnastics isn’t an issue when you’re the one doing it.
They then decide to make out as well. And look who sadly has to witness it.
I love how Kaylie’s face whenever she sees something she doesn’t like is a mix of judgmental and constipated. Because same.
Austin comes over to save the day by asking Kaylie if she wants to “make them jealous.” Disguising a weird come on as a chivalrous means of helping her get back at a bad friend is…a choice.
Kaylie, to her credit, says no and speeds away. Her strong will has to erode sooner or later for plot purposes, but for now, I’m proud.
Time for an update on Chloe’s hiring of Bob Fosse. JK, she’s actually gone ahead and gotten the “hottest gymnastics choreographer available,” Lacey Grimes (a porn star name if I’ve ever heard one). Emily immediately rejects this on the basis of the routine costing $2,000, but Lacey’s already coming to the gym.
In the inner sanctum of the Rock office, Summer reveals she’s found a pair of tickets to the ballet that she’s pretty sure is meant for Sasha to take her on a date. Summer, didn’t you see what happened to Emma Thompson’s character in Love Actually when she found the necklace? It never. Works. Out.
Payson and Kaylie practice their routines, and they’re truly serving North Korea realness.
Austin invites Kaylie and Emily to a party. Emily is clearly interested but Kaylie’s like why would I dance at a frat rager when I could dance like this to my mid-90’s banger floor music in a hot gym?
The mysterious Lacey Grimes arrives at the gym ready to rehearse with Emily and she brought her best bikini top for the occasion. Is it ever pool weather in Colorado?
Like Julianne Hough watching Napoleon Dynamite, Lauren fumes at this sad display and asks her father why he couldn’t have hired Lacey Grimes for her instead. Turns out he was the one who tipped Chloe off to hire her in the first place. Lauren probably could have still arranged to work with Grimes, but she was too busy going on a date with Carter that he probably didn’t pay for.
Summer gets excited when Sasha asks her what she’s doing that night, but it turns out he’s just asking to make sure she’ll be at the gym while he’s at the ballet…with Payson!
He says it’s just to expose her to more artistic performers, but based on this weird display of the two of them looking like they’re going to prom, I’m not convinced.
Sasha looks like he just had to shake Payson’s dad’s hand and the handshake was just a little too tense.
During an uncomfortable dinner, it’s clear Kaylie’s mom doesn’t agree with Alex’s management tactics, particularly the choice of her floor music. To keep the peace, Kaylie suggests that her music be a remix of Gershwin-esque Americana and…club music. Alex, I’m gonna agree with you here.
Although, hey, if it worked for Olivia Karas in 2019, maybe it could here too.
Outside the ballet, Payson tries to get Sasha to rethink this whole ballet thing and just go drink instead. Well, drink sparkling cider, that is. But I have to say drinking is probably preferable, too.
Emily’s having just as much fun doing choreography in the gym when Austin walks in. He says he can kind of relate to her plight of being the black sheep: He lived in a van for three weeks while training in Dallas. Then he offers to take her on a not-date to the Pizza Shack. Ladies, any man who says he relates to you then offers to take you to the former workplace you left in disgrace…doesn’t really relate to you.
Payson is enjoying the ballet more than she thought, even with Sasha offering weirdly voyeuristic interpretations into her ear the whole time.
At the Pizza Shack, Austin blows away any previous image of him as a humble everyman by telling Emily to suck it up and pay the $2,000 because it means she’s going “all in.”
Easy to say when you probably dropped $2,000 on motorcycle improvements in 2009 alone.
Lauren comes in and is gleeful to see all this unfolding. Because it means Emily is defying Kaylie? Because she’s spending less time working with Lacey and therefore probably going to bomb her floor routine? Because she loves drama? She postulates and Carter reaffirms to her that she’s just as talented as Emily the pizza eater. So she did it to fish for compliments. Okay.
Payson and Sasha meet the ballerina who dazzled them onstage, and it turns out she’s a stocky tomboy just like Payson.
Yup, that’s the label she got. This is why girls question themselves.
At the gym the next morning, Summer passive aggressively storms out when Sasha mentions the ballet, so Kim gets real with him.
Who was talking about relationships and dating in third grade? Raise those hands up, wow there’s so many of you I’m having trouble counting…
Speaking of relationships, Kaylie shames Emily for daring to be seen in public with Austin, which Lauren tipped her off about. Lauren, sensing a Emily’s vulnerability, asks why she can’t be “just friends” with boys, which she mixes in with a reference to Carter being in love with her to make sure Kaylie doesn’t get her just desserts.
It’s time for the showcase performance of the new floor routines. Fueled by the anger of knowing about Carter and Lauren, Kaylie gives an impassioned performance that gives new meaning to the the concept of a reanimated corpse. Picture the Roger Rabbit but even more disjointed/heavily medicated.
On the bright side, mutual hatred of this routine might just rescue Kaylie’s parents from the throes of divorce. Hopefully they can invest the money from attorney’s fees into a better choreographer.
Next, Lauren delivers a sensual routine to the tune of a 1930’s New York strip club burlesque track.
After our long national nightmare *ahem* the showcase concludes, Sasha finally works up the courage to ask Summer out. 
On the bright side, at least this (hopefully) rules out any question that the previous night’s dalliance at the ballet was nothing more than a weird way to tell someone to be more artistic. 
Balance Check
Every week we will break down the little moments that stood out as being extremely on point and those that wobbled a bit too much. Shout out to Vulture and its Gossip Girl Reality Index for providing the template for our version.
Faker Than Lacey Grimes’s “Choreographer” Credentials
- “I want you to think like an artistic gymnast and that means starting your routine in the center [of the floor].” What in the witch doctor science? Minus 5.
- $2,000 for choreography sounds suspiciously low. Minus 3.
- Steve believing Lauren when she said she spent last night studying. Minus 4.
- A national team choreographer letting Kaylie walk out onto a performance apparatus with that choreography. Yes, it’s supposed to be USA Gymnastics, but they have some semblance of standards. Minus 6.
- That way Sasha asked Summer out? Only in the movies. Minus 6.
Total: -24
Realer Than Austin’s Lack of Creativity in Deciding Date Spots
- The Rock girls’ reactions to Emily arriving with Austin to the gym. In every friend group, there’s mutually agreed men who are off limits, especially when those men are directly getting in the way of your success. Plus 5.
- Lurking and getting your feelings hurt. Welcome to the club, Summer. Plus 7.
- The presence of a gender binary that allows for a discussion on artistry versus power in gymnastics and how it dogs Payson. Wish I didn’t have to “plus” this, but it’s not wrong. Plus 5.
- Those reactions in the crowd to Kaylie’s routine. Gymnastics fans are judgemental! Plus 4.
Total: 21
MIOBI earned a -3 this week, which should represent Chloe’s credit score after springing for that expensive choreography.
Total: -24
Realer Than Sasha’s Inability to Read Cues
- Austin and Emily being those last customers in a restaurant who are preventing the staff from cashing out. Every retail worker knows them. Plus 5.
- Bidding wars for choreographers sounds like the shady backroom dealings we’ve heard about in gymnastics over the years. Plus 6.
- The gender binary that allows for the bad faith discourse of whether being athletic or artistic is more valuable. Wish it wasn’t a plus, but there it is. Plus 7.
- Payson being giddy about drinking sparkling cider as a young kid. It was a rebellious feeling. Plus 4.
Total: 22
MIOBI scored a -2 this week, which represents the amount of choreographers in gymnastics land willing to work with Rock gymnasts after this episode’s goofy display.
Recap by Katherine Weaver
Like what you see? Consider donating to support our efforts throughout the year!
